Sixteen episodes in, Mitti De Baway has reached the confrontation it has been building toward since its first scene – and then refused the payoff viewers expected. In episode 15, Bilqees Bano, known to everyone as Billo, summoned Iqbal Channan, known as Baala, to a meeting neither could walk away from unchanged. Both raised guns. Both wanted to shoot. Neither could. In episode 16, which aired on Thursday, the fallout landed where the show’s harshest critics feared: Baala went back to Billo again, and his own home paid the price.
To understand why that stung, you have to hold the show’s timelines in your head at once. In 1980, in Wazirabad, young Billo, from a respected family, fell for young Baala, the son of a Mirasi family of wedding singers. When Baala’s mother died and he missed a meeting, Billo mocked him as a marasi, then married into the wealthy Shah family, rejecting him for his caste. On her wedding day, a former lover killed her brother, and her own family abandoned her. Sixteen years later they met again in Faisalabad: Billo, now married with two children, begged Baala to keep their past secret. Then came prison, and then the present: Billo remade as Bari Sarkar, a pirni whose followers obey her without question, and Baala a feared man working for Phajja.
The present-day board is crowded. Baala is married twice over – first to Zareena, then to Qamrunnisa, mother of Qadar. His sister Kausar runs his household and treats Qamrunnisa as an intruder; his younger brother Aslam is dead. Billo, meanwhile, has built her power on spiritual authority: she blackmailed DSP Nawaz Khan in episode 14, openly calling it “business.” And Qamrunnisa, who only learned in episode 14 that her husband is the same Iqbal Channan who once loved Billo, went to Billo herself to beg for her marriage.
The turn of episodes 15 and 16 is not the gunfight – it is the refusal to have one. The script has told us these two destroyed each other. The face-off was supposed to be the reckoning. Instead, the guns stayed silent, and what came out was the truth both had been burying: the first love never died. Billo let go of her grudge about her widowhood; Baala admitted, without saying it, that he still loves her.
In episode 16, that admission curdles into something uglier: Baala comes home to find Qamrunnisa and Qadar squeezed into a living arrangement Kausar refuses to dignify, and instead of standing up for his wife, he justifies his sister and offers Qamrunnisa empty consolation. She answers with nothing but “ji… ji…” Then he goes back to Billo. Again. The man who lost his whole life to Billo’s conspiracies walks straight back into them. That is the real turn: the show’s hero has become its most argued-over character. “Balaa phir phisal gaya,” one viewer wrote after episode 15 — Balaa slipped again. After episode 16, the verdict hardened: “Billo is trapping Balaa once again and he deserves it all.”
Baala’s return is not random: it is the one wound he has never been allowed to close. Billo humiliated him at the exact moment of his grief, when his mother died, then built a life on the class contempt that rejected him. Everything he became – the prison term, the robberies, the feared name – was a reply to that rejection. Going back to her is not about romance; it is about finishing an argument that started when they were teenagers. Wahaj Ali plays it as compulsion rather than choice.
Billo’s motives are clearer and colder. Her revenge has a ledger: expelled from the Shah household, her brother dead, her name dragged through mud. She answered by building a different kind of power – spiritual authority, the pirni’s seat, where followers obey and policemen can be blackmailed. When she sent Baala the coded weather message from their youth, it was not nostalgia – it was a summons from someone who knows exactly which door to knock on.
The setups are paying off: the weather code returns as the instrument of the face-off, DSP Nawaz’s secrets become her leverage, and Qamrunnisa’s suffering is now the moral centre of the show – the person with the most to lose and the least power to stop it. The pacing, though, is where the show starts to wobble. The gunpoint confrontation was earned over fifteen episodes, and the show was right to stage it slowly. But the aftermath is rushed past the people it hurts most: Aslam’s death is mostly a grave visit, while the camera hurries back to Billo, and Qamrunnisa’s storyline is stretched in the wrong direction — episode after episode of her being diminished at home, with no scene that lets her push back. The themes are ambitious – caste, class, first love curdling into revenge – but the show spends its time on the romance and leaves the social argument half-made.
What works is the sheer craft of the central pairing. Mahira Khan’s Billo is the most commanding presence on Pakistani television: she plays the pirni’s stillness as power. Wahaj Ali matches her by doing the opposite – his Baala is all barely contained feeling, and his best moments are the ones where he says nothing at all, like the episode 6 scene where he weeps inside while keeping a calm face. Together, their chemistry is why the gunpoint scene lands: two people who destroyed each other and still cannot pull the trigger. The non-linear structure works too, cutting between timelines to argue that caste and class wounds don’t heal, they compound.
What doesn’t work starts with Baala himself. The fan backlash after episode 16 is not a misunderstanding; it is the audience correctly identifying that the character has stopped growing. A man who has lost his brother, watched his first wife and son walk out, and married twice cannot keep returning to the woman who engineered his ruin for no reason beyond “first love.” First love is a motive, not an excuse, and the script is treating it as one. The second problem is Qamrunnisa: the show’s most sympathetic character, reduced to a woman who says “ji… ji…” while others decide her life. And the third is carelessness at the edges – a makeup continuity slip on Mahira Khan in episode 15 became a meme, and the background score is heavy enough to flatten moments that would work better in silence.
What to watch next is speculation, but the threads point the same way. Zareena’s possible return looks set to be the next detonation – a first wife walking back in would force Baala to answer for both marriages at once. Joji’s interest in Sitara could pull DSP Nawaz’s secrets back into the open – and if the DSP decides Billo’s blackmail has cost him more than it bought, he could turn on her. Qamrunnisa, meanwhile, looks set to reach the end of “ji… ji…” – and Qadar, her angry teenage son, could be the one who finally says what she won’t.
Watching from outside your home country?
Streaming line-ups change by country, and a show available on Netflix or Prime Video at home may not appear when you travel. A VPN like NordVPN lets you connect through your home country and keep watching the services you already pay for. DesiVibe readers can check the current deal here: NordVPN
Current deal: NordVPN’s Black Friday sale – up to 77% off 2-year plans + 3 extra months.
Disclosure: DesiVibe may earn a commission if you sign up through links in this article, at no extra cost to you.
